Oct 27 2007
When will it end?
I watched the Tehelka expose right after I read the Amitva Kumar book, Husband of a fanatic (intensely self promoting piece of tripe but we will leave that for another day). Both the book and the report left me depressed. To see that after 70 years or so, we still identify ourselves by religion first and as Indians later tends to leave one dismayed. And we are predictable in our reaction to any insult - we mobilize a mob and loot.
One thing that astounds me about mob frenzy is how does a sane, otherwise intelligent person be so carried away so as to take another life? I saw it first time as a child, when a crowd looted, burnt and killed the Sikhs in our community. These people had been neighbors for longer than I had lived and yet the Sikhs were declared enemies, because of their faith they were guilty of the crime committed by the Prime Minister’s body guards. I could not understand it then –I kept asking Dad how could they have killed the PM as these men say, they live here. If it was clear to me as a child, why had the adults lost their sense?
I saw communal hatred , as a young girl, grip India again with the Rath Yatra. As the Babri Masjid came down, a friend remarked, “Ab ke hone wale tamashe mein aur kitne log marenge (How many will die in the aftermath of this)?” He was right. My Bombay burnt. And we saw, people kill, burn taxis and buses or loot. Brandishing swords, young men in my neighborhood talked about ‘protecting’ us. The implication was simple – the cops or law would not. Both the factions had young men, in their early to mid twenties, looting, killing - for what? And more importantly, at what cost? Eventually, things got under control and life resumed –but the bitterness, the inherent distrust continues as we see sparks flying time and time again in Bombay.
I was here, far away in the US, at the time of Godhra incident. And I knew that Gujrat would riot. And as Gujrat’s Hindus retaliated, we saw a new low. Gruesome horror enfolded as women were raped, men killed ,butchered actually and burnt to death, right in front of their kids. And as I read the news, I felt a rage. While I had been hurt and saddened that anyone could kill a whole train carriage of men, I was more shocked that the authorities did nothing again to stop this aftermath, this rampaging herd. The cops knew , the leaders knew. And they did nothing. Nothing. Like they did not in all the earlier cases.
It is a lesson learnt in every Indian’s lifetime – each side (substitute any pair of rivalry of the day here) tries to “take an eye for an eye.” For me, living close to Malegaon as a child has reinforced how easy it is to trigger communal hatred. It is as if someone says in the “name of allah or ram”, and we are to set aside our reason and kill. It is puzzling, how the idea of God can invoke one to lose your rationality and consciousness.
What happens after everything cools down? Do the young men who killed have any remorse? Or is still a sign of pride? I cant eat after I put the mice in my laboratory to sleep. How can these people live with slaughtering human beings? How do you accept a killer into your polite society? What is the difference between him and any other murderer? Why are the masses silent? This is what disillusions me. Instead of moving forward, it seems that time and time again, who ever rules, controls the police, the law is then set aside and for a few hours or days in the name of our God, we can be animals.
Is this the price one pays to be free? Do our leaders represent us? Are they doing or encouraging what we want? If not, why aren’t the people objecting? Is it because it is worth sticking with a devil we know?
Or is it because deep down, in India, we are a fractured society?
PS – read Rohit’s call for Modi to resign. I agree with him that Modi has to take moral responsibility for this disaster.